This place is not for everyone but we really enjoyed ourselves. We just used it as an outpost for seeking out the best beaches Eleuthera has to offer (and there are plenty). The best parts were the outdoor shower, the chickens roaming the yard at all hours, and the funky herb/veggie gardens out back. The efficiency kitchen was nice but... More

If you are looking for a touristy, trendy place with lots of other people this isnt it. We had great time relaxing and enjoying the island at a slow pace fitted to our needs. Owner knew the island well and went out of her way to make sure we saw the real island and its wonderful friendly people. Got to... More

My fiance and I visited Kimberly's place in August of 2009 and it was absolutely wonderful. Those have posted that this is not this Hilton and it is not but it is a close to home as you will ever find. Kimberly and Hensil were most accomodating. They made sure that we had everything that we needed. Hensil was most... More

i can't believe its over. im so tan. i feel so healthy from eating food grown in Kimberly's garden. the most sweet watermelons, mango, and papaya ever!. i have seen some of the most crazy things on this trip. caves that go from one side of the island all the way to the other. i jumped off of an 80... More

My boyfriend and I both chose Eleuthera because it was someplace that we both have not traveled to. Words cannot describe how beautiful this island is. When I talk about the BEAUTY i dont mean just the overall look of the island. I am talking about the PEOPLE. The people is what makes this ISLAND more APPEALING and ENJOYABLE and... More

I'm from Barcelona, Spain, 23 years old. my english is not very good but I will try to writte in english because i want that a lot of people can understand my review. Me and my girlfriend spended 2 weeks in starfish cottage in december 2009, before this we spended 2 month travelling arround USA and it was the perfect... More

My family and I stayed with Kimberly after the Round House we rented week ran out (although the housekeeper at roundhouse offered to let us stay extra days if we bribed him under the table). We moved up to Kimberly's place. Affordable. Wild stories and lots of ancient artifacts on site there -- it's a historic place and it's true... More

I am another person who was suppose to stay here with my friends, we were told that the place "wasn't for us" and handed our money and sent out to find somewhere new after hours of travel and it getting dark out. Some nice man of Kims did drive us around looking for another place but it doesn't matter, she... More

What a piece of heaven!!! I was fortunate enough to have found the Starfish, on a stay in Gregory Town. I cannot say enough. It is out of this world. Located on the cliffs overlooking the town and the turquoise waters of the Caribbean; the Starfish offers all the convenience, and yet, solitude you could desire. Absolutely breathtaking gardens; are... More