...as I would prefer this motel stay unknown to people so I could continue getting rooms here at the reasonable rates they have. But fair is fair - good performance should be rewarded. I understand some of the negative reviews for it, as expectations seem to be different for higher-userrated hotels and motels. My giving it 4 stars does not... More

Gladly surprised of a clean/comfortable(big) overlooking the LI sound room in a nice Inn in a quaint little town. The room had a nice table and 2 chairs where we were able to play Clue. They have a restaurant where you can sit and enjoy the LI sound. We went early, before the kids got up, and enjoyed a cup... More

I agree with the positive reviews about what a hidden gem this is. Very authentic, down-to-earth, honest and great quality for the price location (and adjacent restaurant). Owned by the same family for 55 years and the pride in that shows. On the beach and worth getting the beach view balcony. Free wi-fi and parking - no elevator apparent, but... More

Must say I was skeptical about this place because the price was very reasonable for a beach front hotel but I was pleasantly surprised!! We got a second floor room (king bed) overlooking LI sound. Check-in was speedy without problems. There looks to be 7 second floor rooms that overlook LI sound. The first four are o.k. and are located... More

My husband and I just wanted to get away for a couple days-and not go to far from home-a friend told us about the restaurant 1st (which is wonderful-has the BEST hot lobster rolls!) and then mentioned the Rodeway Inn-so looked it up online and got reservations. I was a little leery as we had never seen this motel before... More

Our friends (2 adults and one child) and we (two adults) spent there one weekend. It was a good choice. Check in was fast and very friendly. We followed advice from fellow TripAdvisor members and had second floor rooms, facing the water. It was nice to sit on a balcony, having a cold one and watching the sunset. Well, décor... More

Not the smartest hotel we have ever stayed in but the room was large, clean, and bathroom was good. Now, the location. On the beach, we had an ocean facing room with a balcony, we had to ask for a second chair but that was brought to us immediately. We sat outside until early evening enjoying the views and peace... More

as many of the other reviewers have said, this is an older beach front hotel, last renovated a few years ago. BUT - you open your patio door and there's the beach, the ocean, and in the distance Long Island. AND its far enough from I-95 there's no highway noise - the quiet is excellent. Even though the room's furnishings... More

I don't usually write reviews unless I find something bad and I like to alert other travelers. But this place is so great that I must review it. I stayed with my girfriend at the king bed oceanview room for 2 nights (4th of July weekend). The location: Quiet residential aerea with nice houses, lot's of trees... simply heaven, Beatiful... More