Just completed my second stay at Island City House. This time, I stayed in the Cigar House. This is not only one of my favorite hotels on the island, but one of my favorite places to just spend some time. The Cigar House as very nice. I enjoyed the balcony that overlooked the pool. The room is very large and... More

Our stay in the Cigar House was wonderful. The suite was charming, clean and the location to Duval St. and the Wharf was perfect. This property is set back off the street, so in the evening it's very quiet. We won't hesitate to stay here again when we return to Key West!

This was our second visit to Key West, our first visit to the Island City House Hotel. We selected this hotel for the location, the very reasonable price and the availability of the kitchen suites. All of my dealings with the hotel prior to and during our visit were friendly and professional. We had no problem finding parking close by... More

From the moment of our arrival to our departure four days later, no-one welcomed us to this rather expensive hotel. After 6pm there is no member of staff on the property in spite of the high cost of staying there. This one might expect from a low cost family run B&B. On the day of our arrival, having driven from... More

We love coming here stayed 3 times but what lets the review down is the cost it is pricey ! People very nice and good breakfast - full of character but will probably stay somewhere less expensive next time !!

My husband and I made our very first visit to Key West at the beginning of March. I was directed to this Inn by a local innkeepers organization and was I lucky! I wanted close access to the action of the town, but also wanted a safe, private place to relax; this was the perfect choice! Located in the historic... More

Island City is a great choice. Rooms are clean and comfortable. Mine had a kitchen, living room, separate bedroom, and private balconey. The room didn't share a wall with another room and was amazingly quiet. The grounds are beautiful and well kept. The location is great and the crowd it draws is tame (and normal) enough where your stay won't... More

This was our second stay at ICH, and this time we stayed for a whole week. I really LOVE this property! The location cannot be beat. It is very near to the "party" that is KW, but far enough away to allow for a quiet, comfortable night. The property itself is beautiful - thoughtful landscaping and you get a feel... More

This was my first stay at this hotel altho I have stayed elsewhere in Key West in the past. This is a wonderful lodging, including a pool, continental breakfast, and lovely porch if you get a room that has one. There are several on the property. The best part is the location to all things Key West. Short walks to... More