We booked one night on the way to Key West in cottage 1 (waterfront). As soon as we pulled in just before sunset, we wished we were staying longer. The grounds are beautiful, and the cottage interior was charming. We enjoyed the big waterfront chaise lounges as the sun set and a the dark settled I'm with warm breezes and... More

My husband and I had the pleasure of having a small vacation, sans children, thanks to the generosity of our parents. I wanted to choose a place that I had never stayed at before but close to where we usually stay when we visit the Keys. I read about Island Bay Resort being in the Top list of resorts for... More

Thanks to TripAdvisor for helping us find this place. Mike and Carol have a beautiful little resort where you feel like you are staying at a friends house. They gave us a ton of good recommendations for things to see and places to eat. The beach was very comfortable with a great view of the sunset. We went for a... More

My wife and I just got back from our seventh annual stay at Island Bay...we would NEVER think of staying anywhere else in the Keys. Mike and Carol are the consumate hosts and very knowledgable about the area. The grounds are immaculate...Mike is always working on something. (He's so hardworking I actually end up feeling a bit guilty for being... More

My husband and I spent 2 nights at the Island Bay Resort, and we loved every minute of it. The decor, landscaping and rooms were adorable. The entire atmosphere was tranquil, calm, relaxing, and welcoming. We loved all the chairs, hammocks, and tiki huts on the property. The entire place, including the rooms are well furnished, clean, and extremely well... More

Just got back from a week in the keys. The Island Bay Resort is perfect if you are looking for a quiet relaxing getaway! The little villlas reminded me of the carribean. Clean, nicely decorated and all the amenities you need. The landscaping and detail to the property is very charming. Mike and Carol are great and all of their... More

This resort is small but that is the beauty of it. If you like peace and quiet then this place is for you. Mike and Carol are the owners and are awesome people. They are very friendly and will tell you all the good places to go around there. The location is close to shoping and dinning. They have Kayaks... More

My husband and I stayed here for 2 nights-- I wish we could have stayed for more!! Our cortage is small, but clean, comfortable, and well decorated--very nice bathroom too. We got an "efficiency" room, so there are bigger units here if you want something more roomy. The grounds are maticulously kept, with lots of beautiful palm trees, flowers, and... More

As soon as we arrived everything looked great , The property is clean very well maintained and beautiful! The rooms are clean and look great with their own themes , the beach area is organized clean and inviting do not miss the sunsets they are fantastic! Also My wife and I went kayaking , Do Not leave with out taking... More