This is a nice affordable option for the Vineyard; it would be hard to find a better value. That being said, there are definite drawbacks here. The units vary greatly in terms if their condition, upkeep and cleanliness. Each unit is owned individually and therefore there is no consistency to the condition of the units. We stayed in one that... More

They do not have a/c which we knew but the two fans that they gave us did not work as the humidity was high. The dishes and silverware in the cupboard were dirty so I washed all of them in the sink. The resort is in a nice quiet part of town and walking distance to Edgartown which was very... More

Bring grill tools, fishing poles, bikes and beach equipment. Hotel has great location to town, restaurants, stores, bike paths, island transportation, has a great pool, comfortable room accommodations, wireless internet service, Cable TV, free parking, On-site laundry facilities & outdoor grilling. An affordable spot that doesn't have A/C in rooms. Hotel Management are friendly & welcoming. Great family spot -... More

We stayed here at the end of last June and we wera all very pleased and surprised with the property. You can't beat the location, value and amenities for the rooms. We travel quite a bit and have stayed at vast array of properties across the spectrum. I will be the first to tell you that you shouldn’t let the... More

We have been staying at Edgartown Commons since 1995 and consider it a home away from home. Our room is always immaculate and the staff is always professional, friendly, and helpful. We enjoy taking note of the improvements each year. Last year we were greeted by new wide-screen TV’s and wireless Internet access. Over the years the furniture has been... More

Recently finished our 16th vacation at the edgartown commons. Perfect place for singles, couples, families with children.Location is perfect. With jan and rick there, it is like coming home to family. Already booked for july 2011!

This is our fourth year staying at the Edgartown Commons. The bedrooms are spacious and have a nice size area for living/eating space. Many rooms have a private deck with patio furniture as well. They also have plenty of picnic tables and outdoor grills. We go the end of June and get a 2Bdrm for $135. For the money and... More

We have stayed at Edgartown Commons now for 12 years. We come the 4th of July week and each year we see a lot of the same families. Usually there are 3 to 5 other families with us. It is a great place for families with Children young and old as there is so much to do.. Since each unit... More

I was looking for reasonable accommodations to visit my son who is summering in Edgartown. This was so perfect... kitchen, living room, bedroom, pool and a minute walk to town. I would have stayed all summer if I could have.