My family and I stayed in Edgartown Commons in September of 2012 and we found it to be the best value in Edgartown. The rates are about $100 / night less than anything else we found (B&B's and hotels) and it has an outdoor pool and kitchen in the units. The location is awesome; just around the corner from the... More

We stayed (2 adults and 2 kids) 3 years in a row, because the price, its clean and has a good location, please don't expect much more.... just a basic hotel with a great location, you can take the bus to anywhere from there.

We stayed here for 2 nights last summer in the middle of a larger new England trip. Loved the ability to get around on buses, loved the kitchen with full size fridge, loved the washer dryers so we could clothes washing mid week. Bed wasn't great, but enjoyed the living room and opportunity for the family to spread out. Would... More

My parents and I stayed here while attending a wedding over Labor Day weekend. We truly enjoyed it, and the location is absolutely perfect! A couple weeks after returning home, I realized that I had left a Lilly Pullitzer dress at the hotel. By the time I was able to call the hotel, they were closed for the season; however,... More

I stayed in room #22 with two queen sized beds in the bedroom and a living room with a small kitchen. It had tons of windows and a great atmosphere. While I've read that they don't have air conditioning, I was there in October and their heat definitely worked! They have good water pressure and well heated water. They furniture... More

After reading all the reviews of the Edgartown Commons hotel/condo we (family of 5 - 3 kids under 10) thought we'd give it a try because of the price, space and kitchen facilities. After staying for a few nights I'd have to say I agree with the two/three star folks and the four/five starers as well. It's really dependant on... More

edgartown commons is like our 2nd home. it gets better each year. we look forward to seeing all the same people who are there the same week .jan and rick are like family. our dates are set for 2013. can't wait.

The price was OK...for Martha's Vineyard, basically $130/night. When we booked they knew we had 4 people. It sleeps 5. When we arrived the bedroom had a single and a queen and the living room had a fold out couch that had seen better days. The walls and ceiling were paper thin. There was no air conditioning and the humidity... More

This is a nice affordable option for the Vineyard; it would be hard to find a better value. That being said, there are definite drawbacks here. The units vary greatly in terms if their condition, upkeep and cleanliness. Each unit is owned individually and therefore there is no consistency to the condition of the units. We stayed in one that... More