My boyfriend and I stayed here over Columbus Day weekend this year, and had an absolutely wonderful experience. We arrived a little early, and we able to check into our room ahead of schedule. The inn keeper was a sweet woman who took some time to explain the place to us, and told us just to let her know if... More

Was in town on business and was put up at the Inn. It's very basic and totally acceptable. Clean and friendly staff! The room I was provided had a shared bathroom which was not ideal as the bathroom and shower are separated individually from the room and located near an entrance that can be used by breakfast guests from 8am... More

We arrived to a musty room and very damp feeling!!! the Innkeeper very snooty attitude... The main buiding charming the rest of the place a dump!!! No tv no phone never told about that! Wanted money uo front before even seeing the room! I would never stay there again thank God barely went back to room except to try and... More

I planned a vacation this year that included about 6 places to visit and wanted to make Marthas Vineyard one of the stops but in order to do that I had to watch my budget and was truly happy to find an affordable room at this establishment. It was clearly explaned to me right up front when making the reservation... More

Have stayed at the Inn several times. Great location, clean & comfy. Charming place with large front porch for relaxing. No frills, but perfect for a getaway.

Old fashioned but quite comfortable and a bargain in season. Very happy with the location, can walk to everything in Edgartown but far enough away from the main drag so it's not noisy. Was on the island for a business-related event, the inn is not set up for business but then again nothing much on the island is! Worked out... More

The Edgartown Inn far exceeded our expectations in every sense. We would definitely stay there again. They have free parking, although, our rental car stayed in the lot most of the time, as shops and restaurants are all very walkable. The Edgartown Inn is a great value, and even though breakfast is not included, you'll find that the Inn's $10... More

Charming, immaculate, very friendly and helpful staff and wonderful location. Love the history of the inn. Has a great porch to view the comings and goings of Edgartown. Wonderful yet simple accommodations and very fairly priced. Not for those looking for a fancy hotel but who seek the charm of a well maintained 200 year old inn.

I had such a pleasant stay at the Edgartown Inn. I stayed here with my boyfriend and we stayed on the third floor for two nights the weekend before Memorial Day. Sorry, but I can’t remember the name of the room. The room had a private bath with a small deck outside. That was cool and after a day of... More