I recommend Captain S's without any misgivings. This is a place where both men and women can feel at home. So many BnBs overemphasize the feminine, and leave men to feel they are trapped in an exclusively woman's world -- enduring their stay for the sake of their better half's happiness. The perfectly appointed decor, plentiful antiques, 'country store' scent... More

When you look up the definition of Bed & Breakfast you should see a picture of Captain Schoonmaker’s and the owners Judy and Bill. We’ve only stayed at two other B&B’s and this was the best by far. I will always compare any other B&Bs I stay at to this one. Judy and Bill make you feel right at home.... More

We enjoyed the quiet beauty of nature here. Our stay in the Captain's Quarters was fantastic! Judy & Bill, the owners, prepared a delicious breakfast and offered wonderful hospitality. We felt right at home without the responsibility that comes with home. Would definitely love to stay here again!!

I would definitely stay here again. We ended up here by chance, due to a bad pouring rainy day on a road bike ride. The owners were friendly and available even without reservation. Breakfast was good.

This is what a Bed & Breakfast should be... that's why I keep going back for over 2 decades- plain & simple...!

I have so much to say about this B&B that I don't know where to start! It was a perfect 1 year anniversary getaway. It was both of our first time at a B&B and we both are so happy we choose Captain Schoonmakers. Bill and Judy were amazing host and made sure they did everything they could to make... More

A much needed respite from the City, my boyfriend and I spent the weekend at Captain Schoonmaker's. It was our first B&B experience and it - by far - exceeded expectations. It was so charming - the rustic carriage house (where our room was), the stream and waterfall on the property, antiques everywhere, fireplaces for our use, the quirks of... More

Bill and judy were great hosts. Judy was extremely warm and friendly and cooked a sumptous and very varied breakfast. We really enjoyed the communal breakfast table as we are British and this was a great opportunity to meet other folks. We stayed in the carriage house and enjoyed the sound of the waterfall and watching deer and other wildlife.... More

My fiance and I stayed at Captain Schoonmaker's in 2008, and decided to go back for a mini-honeymoon after eloping in NYC. All I can say is that Judy and Bill made the experience such a special one, both times. The inn itself is cozy, warm, and inviting. The rooms are beautifully decorated and very comfortable. Eclectic books are all... More