As beautiful as Eastern Long Island is, I have often avoided it because I experience too many entitled, petite rich people with pretentious attitudes. In general, though, the folks on the North Fork tend to be more real than than those of the South Fork. The owners of the Mattituck Motel, Kerry and Melinda, are Real People who will provide... More

If you're used to modern hotels and motels, this old gem just might be the change of pace place you can really enjoy. As a well traveled professional musician, I've stayed and played in the best of France, Switzerland, St.Barth's, St. Thomas, cruise ships, etc., and this has to be one of the best little spots my wife and I... More

The Mattituck Motel was something you would picture out of the mid 1960s. It doesn't pretend to be something that it's not. The location was fine (you need to drive anywhere you want to visit in North Fork - this hotel was not in walking distance to anywhere). I found it strange that I had to mail a check to... More

I tried to book a room through the owner. After speaking with him a few times and learning that he had rooms available for the upcoming weekend, he would not rent out a room for just one night. BAD BUSINESS!

I travel once a year from Arizona to the North Fork of eastern Long Island, N.Y. to visit friends/family and to visit the place where I grew up. Although I usually stay in Greenport, this year, for nostalgic reasons, I decided to try the Mattituck Motel. I went in mid-October, when the fall color is beautiful, the beaches are deserted,... More