We wanted to escape from New York (see what I did there..?) and this proved to be the perfect place. We fell in love with the little island and its old world charm. The house is lovely, quaint and full of old world charm. The owners (I forget there names..) were also great, very helpful and entertaining. On the island,... More

My fiancee and I had a wonderful time at the House on Chase Creek. The property was absolutely beautiful, very clean and in a stunning location. We had breakfast in a room overlooking the river and best of all being a boutique place we didn't see anyone else the whole time we were there. The owners were extremely helpful in... More

The location is the best part of this b&b, overlooking chase creek. Very pretty in the morning with the sun shining on the creek, and yes, a deer trotted by at breakfast. The house itself is very average. Nothing special. The bedroom was clean, the linens nice, toiletries consisted of soap and shampoo and were very average. We were in... More

My husband and I just returned from a getaway to Shelter Island, and we chose this establishment because of it's high rating on TripAdvisor. Lo and behold, it lived up to the high expectations--from the lovely location across from the creek, the cozy and comfortable room (we had the downstairs suite) and hospitality of the hosts, Sharon and Bill. Bill... More

We stayed at the House on Chase Creek while visiting Shelter Island for a wedding this summer. The house sits on a lawn bordering the water (the "creek" not the ocean), a couple minutes' walk to the downtown part of Shelter Island Heights. We stayed in Room 3 (the "economy" room as we were told). It was like visiting an... More

We just returned from 2 nights at House on Chase Creek. We had the suite on the first floor which was spacious and comfortable. Bill and his wife were very friendly-Bill especially enjoyed conversing with the guests. We enjoyed our stay, but our only disppointment was the breakfast. Whenever we have stayed at a B&B we have had delicious a... More

We stayed for a Saturday and Sunday night get-away on one the hottest weekends in memory. As luck would have it both my girlfriend and I had terrible colds and we spent most of the weekend around the house. What a pleasure! The house is large, immaculately clean, decorated beautifully and very welcoming. The breakfast was outstanding with cereal, waffles,... More

This was our first time staying on Shelter Island and we are so glad we chose The House on Chase Creek. It's a perfect location, quiet & serene, beautiful, clean and what an excellent value! We stayed in one of the rooms on the second floor. We got to take a peek in all the rooms, each very lovely. The... More

Escape from the pressures of modern life in this lovely jewelbox overlooking nature at its best. Who needs TV when inside, antiques and charming decor abound. And outside, just past the porch swing shaded by colorful trees, a hammock and chairs beckon from the bank of a shimmering creek. The Continental breakfast has an air of elegant simplicity in the... More