My husband, daughter (age 11) and I stayed at Pillow and Pantry recently on a visit to nearby Colgate University. We could not have asked for a more lovely experience. This B&B is beautifully decorated, comfortable and super clean. There are hardwood floors throughout, which I really appreciate. Our guest room was quiet, charming and had a private bath. The... More

Pillow and Pantry was our first B&B experience. Since our first visit, we have returned several times. Each time we were welcomed by a Peg and Jim to a warm and friendly atmosphere. The accomodations were great and breakfast was always delicious. Their attention to detail showed throughout the home. As avid travelers we were very impressed. We will definately... More

This is what a B & B should be. The feeling of staying in someone's home with lovely antiques and delicious breakfasts, each room clean, charming, comfortable and well-appointed. The owners are very attentive to every need and Peg is a super chef. Breakfasts are filling but elegant, plenty to keep you going for the day! Other B & Bs... More

We were at an artist's reception at nearby Golden Gallery and loved our stay at Pillow & Pantry. It was clean and comfortable, with wonderful small touches. The decor was lovely and it was obvious that great pains had been taken to make guests feel at home. Peg made a gorgeous breakfast which included the best & lightest banana muffins... More

This was my first B&B experience and I couldn't have been more delighted. Peg and Jim have done an incredible job restoring their house. You get the best of two worlds - gorgeous antiques and Victorian decor blended with modern conveniences. Meticulous care has been taken in each room. If you have allergies or asthma this is a great place... More

When visiting family, all we needed was a comfortable room with a private bath. What we found at Pillow and Pantry was that and more. It's a gem! Jim and Peg have done a beautiful job restoring the house so that it has Victorian charm with modern amenities. Our room had a comfortable queen-sized bed, with pillows of assorted firmness.... More

Staying at the Pillow and Pantry in Sherburne, NY was a delight. It’s picture perfect facade and garden entry was just the beginning of a fairy tale. The owners Peg and Jim Jeffrey have refurbished the Victorian period woodwork and furniture all through the house. Together with modern conveniences their attention to detail, I appreciated both the visual aspects of... More

We were in town for a wedding in July. The bride and groom to be told us about this place. We had our choice of rooms. Our friends took the downstairs room. It was very nice. Just like being at home. We took one of the rooms upstairs. Both rooms had their own bathrooms and AC. The whole house is... More

This pleasant Inn located in rural upstate NY was really a wonderful surprise. The owner/hostess, Peg, has put so much love and personal attention into this house that it was just a pleasure to turn every corner and witness its magnificence. You'll find a beautifully restored period Victorian which is walking distance to some local eateries, a short 10 minute... More