We recently stayed a week in the Milburn, in an unrenovated double/double room on the 10th floor. The hotel is in a great location - easily accessible from the 79 and 72 st subways (72 is particularly useful to catch the express trains downtown, which saves a lot of time). It's also close to the M79 bus across central park... More

I spent 12 nights at this hotel. I booked a studio for my daughter and my sister (who arrived later than me). The studio was perfect for two, but little for 3 persons, as there was no room enough to add a third bed. I explained the situation at the front desk, and they changed us into a suite, for... More

Great hotel and would go back/refer others. Friendly service, comfortable room, good mattress. Large lobby, and a PARLOR!!! Dated decor, but not at all shabby. Sparkly clean kitchenette and bath. Large rooms for NYC! Asked for quiet room and mine was on 2nd floor overlooking a roof. Not scenic, but quiet, and that was fine! Service was friendly, quick, and... More

In October 2012 we stayed with our extended family at the Milburn, renting three one-bedroom suites for several days. We hoped to return, because having the extra space for children was very nice, but they were so unpleasant when we tried to work with them around an unavoidable cancellation that we will not stay there again. When we had to... More

Stayed four nights. This is a delightful hotel with an old worldly and lovely atmosphere. The staff were all helpful. If you are wanting to explore the Upper West Side, then the location is ideal. Nearby is a good Italian/pizza restaurant and only a few blocks away is Amsterdam Avenue with heaps of bars and restaurants. The room was a... More

Very good value for money in New York. The hotel is almost a four star hotel. Friendly, helpful staff and very clean rooms. You can walk from the hotel through Central Park and you are in 15 minutes at fifth avenue. Good little restaurants near the hotel and good shopping Loehmanns for clothes and Fairway for great food. We will... More

In January, my husband and I spent a month to be remembered at the Milburn! From the moment we checked in, everyone there went out of their way to ensure we were comfortable. Nothing was too much, in fact even the manager went out of his way to find something special to spoil us with. Our suite was very tastefully... More

There are numerous reviews on this site accusing the Milburn of "bait and switch" tactics, but I stupidly decided to ignore those reviews and focus on the positive ones. I needed to be in the hotel's Upper West Side neighborhood and the price was reasonable. I reserved my "remodeled, upper floor" room from Expedia, where I unfortunately paid for my... More

I've been there for 5 days in April 2013 and that was my second time there. I had the room on second floor, so the views were not so good as the last time, when I got the 7th floor room. But the advantage was that I didn't have to spend to much time in the elevator. I was usually... More