Although a bit more expensive than some of the local alternatives, this hotel has everything you need and delivers it professionally. This property is close to a number of popular destinations and I presume that allows it to charge a "premium" for its location. In my experience this was a decent rendition of the Best Western formula: basic needs are... More

If you're comparing it to a Motel 6 this is really nice. If you're comparing it to a Hampton Inn (they are comparably priced) it pales. There's nothing drastically wrong. Room, bed and bath are clean. Bed is comfortable. However, there are scuff marks near the door and on a wall. Several areas where the wall and ceiling don't join... More

My wife and I recently stayed at the Best Western Plus Turtle Brook Inn and were extremely pleased with the high focus on customer satisfaction and cleanliness of the hotel. We were also pleased to hear that they offered a Breakfast Buffet which included a wide variety of hot and cold breakfast items. Hotel is within close proximity to: St... More

Returned for my High School Reunion. Had a great time. West Orange is a wonderful town. Thomas A. Edison made it his home. Ice Skating across the street at South Mt. Arena (it has another name now but it will always be So. Mt Arena to me). Turtle Back Zoo is behind the Arena. So Mt. Reservation runs through the... More

A group of us stayed at the Turtle Brook Inn for work and were given amazing service! The hotel owners are married couple who inherited the business from one of their parents. They did their best to accomodate our group in every way. The rooms were clean, tidy, and quiet. I would definitely stay here again!

Stayed in the room for 6 days during hurrican Sandy and was a great experience. The bed are firm and comforting. The management team were also nice and caring. The view from room 210 was excellent - look over a recreational center.

I stayed October 12-14, 2012 for family weekend at Seton Hall University. After booking at BW, I found reviews about the hotel and was actually scared to even stay there, but I did anyway. My experience was nothing but purely positive in every way. Andre greeted me and was so helpful by offering to help me with my bags, inform... More

my family and i went to visit some friends in Newark and decided to spend a day at West Orange zoo. the hotel across the street seemed a smart choice! OMG, the room smelled awful, we had hair all over the tub and sink, the sheets looked dirty and had strong cigarette smell and the worst, we were insulted by... More