This was our first night on the island and chose to start it off with fishtails. There fresh catch was really well done and did not disappoint. There are better restaurants but this is great for a laid back casual restaurant.

We were looking for a place with peal and eat shrimp and found out this place served some of the most amazing sushi. Actually some of the best we've ever had!! The staff was extremely friendly and located right on the waterfront. Easy access to the ferry and other evening festivities. Be sure and make this a definite stop on... More

Bad customer service made what would have been a good meal a poor one. Either the waiter or cook messed up on my order for a sushi roll and it took fifteen minutes to bring another out and that was only after I complained. The waiter only had defensive excuses and when I pointed out the fallacy of those excuses,... More

Ate here on our last night on the island and the food was so fresh and absolutely delicious! Got the fried seafood platter to sample and all was cooked perfectly - some of the best seafood I've ever had! The bartender held my card with the bill up until we were finished with dinner even after asking her 3x for... More

While in St. Thomas recently, we asked several of our tour guides where they recommended for dinner, and unanimously Fish Tails always came up. Lots of overpriced restaurants on the island, most of which you're paying for the view or ambiance, but not at Fish Tails. Fish Tails is on the water at American Yacht Harbor, right next to the... More

Few of us wanted lobster, when we ordered they were out! They could of told us that when we entered. The food was good but very pricy

Awesome happy hour and food. Think this is a must when visiting Red Hook. Service is a little slow, but the atmosphere and views are amazing.

I recently had dinner at Fish Tails in Red Hook in St Thomas, US Virgin Islands. To start, I had a memorable dinner about five years ago in Anegada, British Virgin Islands. The lobsters were three pounds, and larger. I had never had lobster that large, they were amazing. Well, I was going to St Thomas for Memorial Day weekend,... More

was great...ate there 3 times...food was very good and prices are right..Located right on the strip in Red Hook and close to the ferries to go island hopping