We ate at Caruso twice. The first evening was a Saturday evening and we didn't have a reservation. However, we received a warm welcome and were offered a seat close to the bar where we could wait 20 or so minutes for a table to become available. The head waiter brought menus for us while we enjoyed a drink and... More

This is our favorite restaurant in Reykjavik. What I love about it that it is same for years. We dined there in 2009 and when came back to Iceland in 2012 found same place, same owner, same great food. Portions are generous, price is reasonable, my favorite dish is lamb fillet with lobster tails.

Beautiful romantic surroundings, excellent food and service - cannot fault it in any way. Tripadvisor says I need to say more - but what more can I add?

We ate here one evening in April and thoroughly enjoyed our meal. Most of our party ate Italian dishes, which were tasty and plentiful. My father had the lamb which he reported to be delicious. The staff were very pleasant and the price was what we expected to pay. Worth a visit.

We had a great meal here. My boyfriend and I both got pasta dishes and they were great! One of our best meals in Iceland! Prices are very reasonable too, and the service was great. Would definitely eat here again when we return to Iceland.

Enjoyed a great Italian Meal here, great service and a thoroughly enjoyable night out. This restaurant is based right in the centre of Reykjavik, and within easy walking distance of many must-see attractions

This restaurant was recommended to us by a friend who had visited. Can I thank him as he was spot on. When we arrived the place was busy and I note the earlier comments about the 3rd floor as that is where we were seated. It may be true that is where the tourists are placed but I can say... More

We booked a table at short notice, thank goodness, as within a few minutes there was a queue at the door! The menu was varied and had clear english translations. In spite of it being so busy, service was excellent; the staff were polite and attentive, nothing seemed to be too much trouble. Our food arrived steamy hot and well... More

Menu looked really good, but when we got in we got shuffled to the third floor where they hide the tourists. Wait staff was short, not very helpful. We placed our order and when we got the food it was bland. I got the scampi pasta and my husband got the lobster pasta. When I tried mine I thought it... More