My mother and I stopped in on our first night in Key West, there was a lovely breeze and with the beautiful parrots outside we couldn't pass it up to dine in their patio area. The birds offer great entertainment while waiting for the food. The service was good but the food was phenomenal. We both ordered the Frutti di... More

I had read the glowing reviews here and made New York Pasta Garden a must on my list for dinners while on a 8 day Key West vacation April 2013. I expected a good experience but what I encountered far surpassed any expectations. It had been a hot day and their location provided lovely early evening breezes to relax and... More

My husband and I stopped in for a late dinner on our anniversary trip and found the ambiance, food, and service to be stellar!

This restaurant is tucked away off of Duval Street so look for it, it's well worth it! Wonderful food, wonderful service, reasonable prices! It was raining the night we were there so we didn't sit on the patio but the patio looked lovely!

Everything we tried was excellent. The lasagna was amazing. Portions are huge and enough for two to share. A bit pricey, but so is everything else on the island.

Had gone on a lovely sunset cruise but found ourselves wanting "a little something" so wandered about; walked past Duval Square and decided to investigate. Found the New York Pasta Garden and had the most delicious pizza, fabulous wine, wonderful server "Jeanette," relaxing surroundings and awesome macaws. We stumbled across this gem and were delighted-definitely a "go to" place and... More

While exploring Key West on our first night in town we found New York Past Garden. The variety of food almost made it too difficult to decide on what we wanted, but our Server was great at helping us to decide. We enjoyed it so much that we decided we had to go back before we left Key West. This... More

We found out about this place walking down Duval St. Were kind of attracted to the inlet from the road by the sound of the macaws. There is a wide selection of food that you have no difficulty to choose from. Complimentary garlic bread was very tasty and bruschettas were well prepared. We all liked our pastas and our server... More

Restauant was recommended by in-laws and it was everything they said it would be. Great service, great meal and in a great location just off Duval St. We enjoyed the entire experience. Our Server, Myles, was fabulous and made the atmospere and meal even more enjoyable, A+. I would recommend this place to anybody and of course recommend asking for... More