Best ice cream I have ever had. Beats all the others including cold stone. Reviews that talk about rude owner is probably from a competitor because no one is rude at this store.

The employee at the Amish Creamery, Madeira Beach, must be a psycho. Today I stopped by at a few minutes before noon. I found the door closed despite a sign (left-side window) that said "OPEN." I tried the door again thinking that it would be a pull-open door that is unlocked. A person parked in front told me that the... More

Have been there twice. Great ice cream both times. Well worth the trip. We also bought two sweet rolls for breakfast. They were gigantic and very yummy. Very friendly employees both times we visited.

Stopped in for some ice cream after a beach day. Had never been to one of these places before. Ice cream portion looks like a typical ice cream parlor. Had all the normal flavors you find these days as well as a few unique ones. In addition to the ice cream they have a small deli counter as well as... More

Great ice cream and they give you lots of it! A single is actually two scoops. And the owner, who is very nice, will give your dog a cup of vanilla ice cream. Our two mutts were in heaven! -- There are benches outside to sit on.

Very creamy ice cream. Nice selection. My nephew dropped his cone on the floor and the owner replaced it with no issues. Try the Chocolate Peanut Butter!

Great, friendly place to stop for delicious, creamy ice cream. It's so good, we even stop in the winter.

Hey Everyone this place is the best. The ice cream is delicious and we had the pleasure of meeting the owner, Clint. What a great guy and so friendly and warm and caring. They had many stores in Florida and just opened a store in San Diego, California. Please g by there and enjoy the most awesome ice cream ever!... More

What can be said, good ice cream and interesting little shop with some other good available. Cash only but that shouldn't be a problem as the prices are reasonable and we're talking ice cream;-)