This by far is not only the best pizza in St Augustine, but it's the best pizza in florida !!!! It's got it all going down, perfect crust, sauce and cheese...forgetaboutit !!! I am from NY and this is it.....enjoy a slice, but bring cash, it's the only thing they take.... p.s. their entire staff treats you like family.... thanks... More

Not a lot of seating, but by the time you get through the line, there is usually some place to sit. There were a TON of pizzas to choose from. I recommend it.

Stopped by here for a quick dinner and got two pepperoni calzones and some of the garlic bread with dipping sauce. The calzones were very good with two or three cheeses but they were HUGE -- one definitely would've filled us both up! The garlic bread bites left a lot to be desired, but it was still a good place... More

The first time a date and I ate here, the pizza was delicious. We were actually surprised at how good it was. The second time we went back a few weeks later the pizza was tasteless to me and my date didn't want to eat any of it. So I'm averaging outstanding with poor to get average for the stars.... More

Needed something quick to eat before the ghost tour. Nothing with a long line or too fancy. We were a little hesitant because we didn't think we would find good pizza in St. Augustine. Pizza was good and there were a few different types you could pick from - we tried regular, pomodoro and margherita. They were all good. I

Went here before the ghost tour, fast and delicious! I ordered 2 slices and could only eat one! Huge! Ate it for breakfast though :)

It had rained the evening we ate at Pizza Time. We liked the pizza, and the garlic rolls. It was good for a slice of pizza. Would we come back for more, not sure. Pizza is really not our thing.

This is a small place with four seater tables along the back wall. There were only about 8 tables. You stand in line to order pay get your food and go to your seat. CASH ONLY. there's a cash machine by the register. Don't be surprised if there's a line out the door. The pizza is excellent. Focaccia pizza with... More

Small restaurant in the hearth of the Old St. Augustine where you can taste the best Italian Pizza by slices in the U.S. - Fresh ingredients and the best Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil make this pizza the best one in the Continental United States. You may also create your own pizza by adding toppings of your choice. Follow the... More