My wife and I ate dinner there and hoped it would be good Italian food since we come from an Italian background in western Pa. The sauce tastes like pure tomatoes with no spices, Italians use lots of garlic! Pizza again was ok but sauce was terrible. We tried the calamari and it was just ok but again sauce was... More

I stopped in Paesano's for lunch by myself one day. Had a Paesano Scilliano.....sub sandwich with bruiscuito, fresh mozzarella, basil leaves, balsamic and olive oil dressing. The sandwich was delicious and the bread was sooooo extremely fresh, which really extremely pleasing!!! The sandwich was huge and generous and presentation wonderful. Definately recommend it if you are tired of eating seafood.

What a pleasant suprise a taste of New York right here in the Keys. Try just a plain cheese pie. It can't be beat. Fresh crispy crust, homemade sauce and perfect blend of cheeses. Yum, been back a couple times for the pie, the entrees look good plan to try them soon.

I loved the atmosphere. The service was great. I love Italian food. They claim New York style pizza. I'll have to check it out next time.

i went there get some garlic-cheese-bread to my boyfriend, and i got the menu to go, he loved it! so did i!!! so the same night we had dinner there...oh my!! the pizza was great, but the best to me were the deserts!!! we were going eat there 4 days in the road!! i dont recomend this much...lol but the... More

I had a great experience. Great service. Great atmosphere. Great food. Great portions and prices. Wil be going to eat there more often and highly recomend.

We stayed a short walk away from this place. It was actually recommended by our front desk. We enjoyed a great Italian meal & wine for a fair price. While service was quick & our waitress fantastic, portions were a bit small. Overall, we would come here again & suggest to others to give it a try as well.