In their lunch buffet, I was able to try a chicago style and the regular thin crust pizza. As a cheese lover, the chicago style was pretty tasty, not just the regular dose of mozarella. Marinara sauce was a little sweet, not as tangy as the sauce on the thin crust. Pretty good deal for the money.

I'm never disappointed with my experience. Not only is the food delicious, they use REAL mushrooms. I hate the canned ones, so every trip to East of Chicago is heaven!!

We showed up to eat here on a Friday evening. The staff here was also very unfriendly. Then, once we had paid, they did not have ONE pizza made for the buffet. We had to wait for pizza to get made and once it was done, everyone ran to get a slice. They were not able to keep up with... More

Maybe we just stopped in on an off day, but as12:30 pm there were only two partial pizzas on the bar. We sorted through many dirty plates in the stacks that had baked on food leftover from the dishwasher. I made a decent salad from the bar but lost my appetite when I found a hair in the lettuce after... More

This place is one of the few open on Sunday for food in this town. They have a great selection, however, deliver to our hotel was not offered until 5pm so we had to wait until the delivery guy came to work to get our food. Other than that, it was worth the wait.

We arrived one evening late and the buffet of pizza looked tired. The lady at the counter offered to make us whatever we wanted and by the time we had our salad finished we had hot excellent pizza.

We were very excited to have found this place hidden off the main trail. We were looking for pizza as an alternative to all the great Amish cooking. We had our 10 year old granddaughter Rachel with us and all 3 of us agreed...this pizza was awesome. We had a large with sausage, pepperoni and green pepper and we didn't... More

The cinnamon knots were very good. The pizza kind of tasted like frozen pizza to me. (Tombstone, to be exact.) It wasn't bad, but it sure wasn't great. There were a lot of people here though so it is a popular place. I guess it just wasn't for me. We had the buffet bar, which they were slow to replenish.... More

We had dinner here one night, they have a buffet which I'm too fond of so we ordered a couple whole pizzas. They tasted great and thanks to a coupon I got off their website they were exceptionally reasonable. Lots of local's eating here and we'd definately go back. Very good!