We've been to Pestos several times over the past couple of years, usually for the buffet. The regular menu is priced on the high side. The food is good but, IMO, priced a little high. Going for the buffet, we get to sample some different entrees and the price is just right. I have to agree with some of the... More

Not good. The food is flavorless and just plain poorly made. I have tried this place a few times on the recommendations of others. This time will be my last. I was woefully disappointed and felt as if i was eating at a poor hospital cafeteria. Sorry guys, it just does not work.

Nice Italian restaurant with specialy pasta dishes make Pestos a pleasant dining experience in Valparaiso. Best time to visit is Wednesday evenings where they present their 30 foot buffet of scrumptious dishes! Salads, pastas, pizzas and uniquely flavored bread pudding keep the crowds coming back. Small bar with nice wine selection is also available.

Everything from their portobello mushroom dejonghe and fluffy amazing breadsticks to their lobster ravioli and pasta with vodka sauce is fantastic. It is reasonably priced with seasonal menus and a good atmosphere.

I'm going to say, my husband and I visited this location twice. The very first time was not crowded, but busy, usual dinner crowd. Service was awesome, food was very good. Wine choices were good. Not too over priced for all. Second time, a little busier, service was average, I tried a peppermint-mocha-tini, which was the special martini of the... More

I love this restaurant! It is my favorite place to dine out. Their service is always great and my favorite dish is the Chicken Milanese. I highly recommend Pestos as one of the best!!

Went there for my birthday dinner and was seated right away. With the high ceilings, the stone work, and wood floor, it was very noisy in the restaurant - nothing to cushion the sound. Waitress was nice and attentive - bruchetta was ok - seemed VERY garlic-y. Dinner was ok too - seemed waaay too spicey for Italian food -... More

Of all the restaurants in town, this is the best! From the time you are welcomed and seated, Pestos provides the best dining experience. My favorite appetizer is the bruscetta, while I recommend the crab crusted seabass. Excellent! If you enjoy buffets, their Wednesday offering leaves nothing to be desired. From salad to breadsticks to pizza to their signature dishes... More

You have to pay a "Share" fee or an extra plate fee. Of course at the time I came they had not put that on their menu. I told this to the manager and she basicly told too bad. So, she lost out any future revenue from my family, friends and myself. Her attitude is what turned me away and... More