Excellent thin crust style pizza. Try the one with goat cheese, onions and bacon. I am a super traditionalist on pizza, but this combo is actually worth it. Not quite Pepes, Sals or all the new NYC Napolitano spots, but darn good for the Cape.

Sweet Tomatoes has great sandwiches that are reasonably priced and come with a side of chips, macaroni salad, or potato salad. The sandwiches are pretty big and definitely delicious! The eggplant special sandwich and bbq turkey are both great.

Went to Sweet Tomatoes tonight for dinner. For an appetizer, I ordered a Caprese Salad which was $8 and was pretty good overall. It consisted of mild mozzarella cheese and lots of diced tomatoes with an olive oil based dressing and some basil leaves and two pieces of foccacia. The tomatoes were not quite ripe, but the portions were large... More

Sweet Tomatoes has consistently good fresh tomato pizza pies. The sausage pizza is a winner.

This crusted pizza, wonderfully fresh ingredients, good value and very popular place. We love it. We also often split a cob salad - generous portions and tasty blue cheese dressing. They serve beer and wine - also reasonably priced and single slices of pizza are available. Whether you eat at the bar, at their spacious tables or take out, this... More

We had a beach house within two blocks of Sweet Tomatoes and went there nearly every night for dinner. You can call ahead to place your order or just order when you arrive which takes anywhere between 10-20 minutes. Lots of comfortable seating on the inside with a nice environment. Pizzas are very big and worth the wait! Highly recommended!