We stopped at Carmine's for lunch after a morning wandering around Chatham. We ate rather a few pizzas whilst on the Cape, but this was definitely the best! Lovely, tangy tomato sauce, heaps of mozzarella and great pepperoni. Our pizza was made fresh and, though we ordered a large and it was pretty big, we could have had another one,... More

We only popped in for a slice of pizza each and were very pleasantly surprised - it was 4pm, we were starving and both slices were fresh and delicious. The cost for Chatham was very reasonable and the lady serving was also very polite so I really cannot recommend this place highly enough.

We wanted a pizza to bring back to our room and Carmine's was perfect. Excellant pizza, many choices of toppings and great crust.

I tried a calzone one evening, it was great. The pizza looked good too but I never got a chance to try it. One of the more reasonable places to eat in downtown Chatham.

My wife and I ordered "The Boss" pizza to go and brought it back to our motel. A small is definitely enough for 2. It was excellent and the crust was crispy.

Pizza made quickly. Something special about the cheese. Pepperoni was typical. Sausage less than average, but tasty.

My wife and I both got different pizzas at Carmine's our first night in Chatham. Both were very good, but it was a bit expensive, which I guess is to be expected since it's right downtown. Their sandwiches seemed more reasonable and pretty good sized.

Fresh and just the way we like our pizza. Plenty of sauce and cheese but with a thin crust that isn't soggy. Grab a pizza with soda's on a Friday night in the summer in chatham and walk over to the Band Concert. #aperfectnight!

This is the perfect spot for a quick bite to eat in downtown Chatham. The pizza is excellent and the service was extremely friendly. A solid local pizzeria.... No frills, but clean and enjoyable.