We loved Matthew's on Main. We stopped in the mid afternoon and enjoyed one of the best hamburgs we have tasted in a very long time. We ate in the small room at the front of the restaurant/pub and felt very comfortable with a lot of locals who frequent this quaint little place. There is a much larger and brighter... More

This is a classic little pub at first glance, then you look at the menu and hope you have your wallet. Price to portion ratio is not well balanced, the ego of the owners are a little over the top and the service unless you are a "regular" is a little to cold side. I have been in there quite... More

menu is small. not a lot of choices but it is good. they are friendly and the bar is a nice place to go.

An earlier review stated that Matthews caters to the locals. While this is true consider that this is a seasonal area so the locals are what keeps them going year round so that we who visit maybe once a year can enjoy the establishment. Our server Mary was really nice and spoke with us as if we were friends. The... More

The only reason I did not give this five stars is because of their prices. For the portions I feel it is a bit over the top. However, if you don't mind paying 25.00 for Salmon it would be an excellent choice.

most people never heard of Callicoon, small town 2 hours ( without traffice) north west of New york on the Delaware River. You have no idea where you are when you get there. it's so quaint with such a feeling of being in the far west with an old and not running train station, an abandonned hotel, small stores (... More

Little out of the way Town, Great Chef & Kitchen. Found this off the beaten path jewel while visiting family in the area. Quants Atmosphere, Cheers type Friendly Bar Scene, Open but Intimate Dinning Room, Great Deck in Season, Down Town Menu Brimming with Originality and Flair , Served with Pride. Matthew the Chef deserves the title, a Talented Innovator... More

I find Matthew's caters to locals who like to drink, and that's fine, but what about us non-drinker's who want to eat? The prices are high for food items and trying to elbow past the drinkers in the front of the place is nearly impossible. Don't even try the Mama Burger. I don't know know who's Mama thought this one... More