We have gone here off and on for years. The fish is always top notch if sometimes overpriced. Recently, we ordered a stuffed artichoke special appetizer. It was a revelation. If on the menu and if you like artichoke, order it and you will not be disappointed.

I ate here with my family and another couple on the Sunday after Thanksgiving, so the restaurant (at which my brother and his family are regulars) wasn't very busy (he says he usually has to call for reservations). It's not easy to serve a party of 10 or more, and the waiter was relaxed and cheerful. Food was outstanding! I... More

I used to live on Long Island, so I have had fresh seafood. I did not like the meal I had here, but other people I know really like the place.(Which is why I gave it a 3 and not a 2.) I guess you need to go to find out for yourself.

I love oysters but I only eat them fried when they are done right. These guys do 'em right. And the fish selection is mind boggling for a mountain town. Good food (try the sweet potato fries)

Hard to find things like octopus and king crab legs are always available in this unassuming international grocery + seafood restaurant. Their frozen seafood section is like nothing I have seen, and holds its own against the best seafood shops in New York and San Francisco

Very good food but not enough,,I was not full when I finished..I will go back because of how delicious my meal was..They also have a nice selection of fresh seafood in their market..Located a few minutes off the NYS thruway and near Suny New Paltz..

This is the best place around. Fish is fresh, looks good, smells good, and tastes good. They even put a bag of ice in the bag to keep it that way.

Dinner at Gadaleto's is a fish lover's delight. This restaurant/fish market provides fresh daily fish and seafood in a relaxing atmosphere with pleasant service and prices that will keep you coming back for more. A daily special of fresh fish available on that day is posted according to fish that is either light, medium or rich in texture. Sides are... More

Great, small fish restaurant. I wrongly reviewed as being closed below.