We have been eating here once or twice each summer for 30 years. Rarely changes but always good food.

i ordered the scallops au gratin and hubby ordered the fried seafood platter we were greeted immediately and the wine came cold and immediately they served the soup of the day at the table in a little crock...lots there to share... the salad was was also served at the table in a large bowl- these two were enough for 4... More

I have then going to the mail for many many years for dinner and have always had excellent food and the service is always phenomenal. But the last 2 * I've gone up in 2011 in 2012 the food was absolutely horrible. My girlfriend and I both decided to have the scrod and it was extremely mushy like it has... More

The Old Mill provides a unique experience: unlimited salad and homemade soup with dinner. The soups are uniformly excellent, and the meals will fill you up. Highly recommended.

Stopped on our way home hoping for a great Sunday dinner like Mom makes. The choices just didn't fit what we were looking for. The French onion soup was good not great but then the nice bread basket was delivered and was delicious. The pork chop was greasy, the mashed potatoes were instant and the frozen veggies cold and under... More

We were advised that the wait was 45 minutes. We waited 90 minutes! Then the service was slow. I ordered Prime Rib, medium well, and it was like it was microwaved. Dry and rubber! My daughters friend had the kids Alfredo and it was cold. Didn't know until a while later and it was too late to get it returned.... More

This was our first time eating at The Old Mill. We weren't disappointed. The staff was super friendly and the dining area was very pleasant. We didn't order any appetizers, but the meal started with a "bottomless" pot of chicken noodle soup and warm bread. I don't typically care for chicken noodle soup, but this was very good. The bread... More

I've visited this restaurant in prior years and was looking forward to warm, fresh bread and great soup, but was extemely disappointed. The bread was not the soft, warm bread I remember and it did not seem homemade. The rolls were dry, pulpy wheat. The salad was iceberg lettuce with a few tomato wedges, green pepper slices, red onion rings... More

The food was excellent. Had to go way back to where we came into Old Forge from our motel to go there but Old Forge isn't that big of a place.