food taste better when you eat with family. my family and i enjoyed this place. friendly staff definitely will go back
Stopped in with a few friends to "catch up" and have a few cocktails. We usually end up in Huntington but this time it was our turn to come East to the town that my buddy John picked. Overall I liked it, many of the towns on the North and South shore are not this close to the water. That... More
Went here for my 40th bday with some friends. It was OK. Service was good, bartender was great but food was average. I expect more from restaurants down port.
Being a local, we've been to Schafers a few times. Gets big points on location. It screams to be great but never closes the deal. Have had a couple of good dinner experiences during the week, and a few nice lunches upstairs on the weekend. The major letdown was Sunday Brunch. I'm not a big fan on brunches to begin... More
Traveled to Port Jefferson for a day trip. Schafers was a nice place to eat with a view on their upper deck of the harbor. The staff was very friendly and helpful which is always nice but the food was somewhat disappointing. My wife and daughter got their fried scallops. Not sure why, but when you bit into them you... More
I've certainly had worse scallops, they were a bit heavy on the breading, which detracted from what seemed to be a quality scallop. Great location and view. Service was just ok on a not so busy afternoon.
A large group went for dinner and to see a band play back in mid July. 10 people ordered food and all 10 said they food was frozen garbage. The staff was rude and several seemed to have calculation problems with our separate bills. 3 of them were upcharged as they claimed mistakes were made. The bar area was absolutely... More
went with 3 couples all our meals were bad much of it was simple stuff fried calamari had to be sent back it was calamari crums thrown in a bowl sushi was like it came from 7-11 it was just all bad hi orice good location eat before you go
Don't bother, they don't get it, food was terrible for all four diners, my meal was taken off the bill, they won't last another year.
Schafers is in a great location, so I want it to be good but its awful. Gets worse each time they change hands. The food was flavorless, just plain not good and the staff was rude. So many places in Port Jeff; I'd never go back here.
If you own or manage Schafers, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing