Second time we've dined here. Nice atmosphere, varied menu and the food can be very good. We were there on a Friday and perhaps 12 other people were also dining. We were there 2 hours and 45 minutes......most of the time waiting for our meal. The waitress was pleasant & took our party's order for appetizers (just soup). She waited... More

I've worked in catering in some high end establishments in the most expensive areas of NYC & Long Island, and have seen and served my share of prime rib. I've eaten in some of the best steakhouses the metro-NY area has to offer, and none of the above ever offered a cut of Prime Rib like the ones we were... More

The atmosphere of this tiny Warrensburg restaurant is very nice with lots of local history behind who Lizzie Keays was. The meatloaf was good, but the pork chops were even better. The homemade desserts smashed our diets, but it was well worth the risks. We never would have found this restaurant had it not been for a friend's recommendation. We... More

We went last night (5/9/13) to Lizzie Keays. From the bread with honey butter to the apple cranberry bread pudding with whipped cream everything was great, The appetizers of bacon wrapped scallops and baked brie with almond raspberry drizzle with garlic bread was out of this world.The sour cream lemon dill dressing for the salad was very tasty.The main course... More

Ate there with friends the day before Easter. We had been before but our friends hadn't. I had a delicious prime rib and everybody in the party were equally happy. The restaurant is carved out of an old shirt factory and is very charming. Wine and beer only but their house wines by the 1/2 carafe is a very good... More

We've eaten here several times, always a pleasure. Staff is thoughtful and attentive. Food is very good and a good value. It's off the main road but well worth looking for. Their specials are always a good choice.

We ate there twice. First time I had eggplant parmigiana. Often, restaurants load up the eggplant with too much batter and bread crumbs. This was light, tender and thinly sliced. Nicely done. Second time had the surf and turf. Most eateries get the turf part right more or less, but too often the surf part is a disaster --tropical lobster... More

We were unaware of this most charming restaurant. This is a real jewel that is definately worth the drive. Set in an old shirt factory, this restaurant offers excellent food at reasonable prices.

We were actually looking for a pub-style, casual dining experience on our first night in town and got much more than we were looking for in Lizzy Keayes. Nightly specials, like the seafood sampler I had for $16.95 put it in the right price category, but the service and atmosphere were definitely a tick up from your typical casual dining... More