My group stopped here after day of exploring the island. The old fashion ice parlour was nice treat. Ice cream was tasty. The parlour had plenty of flavours and options. There was plenty of seating inside and outside with nice prompt service.

Muller's has a great atmosphere! the only bad part was the prices. They were on the expensive side. A more affordable place is Mister Whippy.

I just love this quaint, darling place. I love the squeaky screen door (please don't oil the hinges!) and the fact that they always have Misty of Chincoteague playing on their TV. The aroma of the Belgian waffles makes you think you are in heaven. The ice cream is good but it's the atmosphere that keeps me coming back every... More

Ice cream was fabulous but our son met his match with the double chocolate. The decorations are a bit eccentric but there's lots of historical stuff to read and 'Misty of Chinoteague' DVD playing in the corner.

The portions of ice cream are gigantic. Although the lines may be long, they have a great system that makes the lines move quickly. It is certainly worth the wait.

We have to go here at least once everytime we go to the beach. It is decorated so wonderful and old fashioned. Like a time capsule.

Muller's is an old standard. The ice cream is all homemade using fresh ingredients. They always have some unusual specials. On this visit, one of the specials was not only fresh peach ice cream, but it could be served on warm homemade peach cobbler! They had a sign out front that stated that the orchard they buy their peaches from... More

Muller's is usually the place where my wife and I stop for "lunch" when we stay in Chinoteague. The breakfast at Miss Moll's is so delicious and satisfying, all we need for lunch is one of Muller's ice cream sundaes. We usually have a fresh peach sundae, but the peaches had just run past the season and unavailable, so we... More

My son actually found this place while scouting the island on his scouter. The atmosphere was old-fahioned ice cream palor. The ice cream was delicious. The owners were very friendly.