Ate at the restaurant 2 nites in a row. The first night was amazing, great service, excellent wine and the food was top notch. The only reason I didn't give this 5 stars was because our service the following night was a bit of a disappointment. The restaurant was extremely busy when we arrived at 7:15pm with a reservation. Eventually,... More

This was my husband's 65th birthday, and were not familiar with Orcas restaurants, I contemplated and narrowed my choice between #1 and #3. This was where we ate and it was an absolute hit all around! We did go to the other the next evening, but, the freshness and ingredients here perfectly enhanced the inspired dishes. Service and atmosphere were... More

It's not cheap , but for what they gave us it was equal to prices here in Dallas and the food was very well prepared. Wait staff was really nice and chatted with us about the island and new the food there very well .

Had an absoultely fabulous meal even though it currently off-season on Orcas Island and there were only a few people dining the night we were there. The bread, made on-site, with 100 year old starter, was the best I have ever had. We ate it all. Salads were large, fresh and inspired. My wife had the scallops and I had... More

This is where I take friends when they come to visit the Islands. It's elegant and the food is always great. Good wine list, with a suprisingly low markup.

For our 10th wedding anniversary we returned to Orcas and dined here. We were seated by the window which gave us a great view of the water. The service was friendly, professional and impeccable. The chef creates the cocktails specials and I tried the kombucha (fermented tea) with tea which stands out as one of the best drinks I've ever... More

My husband and I wanted a romantic dinner for two in late October during the off season for the island. The Inn was one of the few restaurants operating mid-week. We had delicious appetizers, and adventurous main course with an incredible dessert. We tried new alcoholic beverages that we have never had and were even delighted with them! Go to... More

Several times here indicates a changing menu with lots of local, home grown ingredients. COntrary to the foolks who didn't like the patio seating, to us it has always been cozy and warm, indicative of the whole place. A very nice wine selection with great desseerts compliments the food, all of which has been good to very good in the... More

My partner and I stayed at the Inn at Ship Bay last November and thought it would be nice to enjoy dinner in their dining room. Too bad that wasn't the case. We were seated in the patio seating, which felt simultaneously cold and drab. It's a semi-confined space that can leave you feeling a bit overtaken by other conversations--especially... More