We asked for a table outdoors (the inside dining area is not large). The two of us split a Caesar salad--bag lettuce (i.e. minimally brown on both cut edges), but a nice dressing which was lightly applied--not smothered and limp like many places. We're not vegetarian, but ordered a large vegetarian pizza, which was fantastic. The 'secret ingredient'? Artichoke, which... More

Sat outside on a gorgeous spring afternoon and had the best pizza I've ever tasted! The wait staff was very attentive. I would drive up to Door County just to have dinner here!

A must visit if you are staying in the area. We went back several times because it was so good. It gets packed in the peak season so plan ahead.

We were looking for a quick and reasonably priced meal around Fish Creek and tried out the Wild Tomato based off other users reviews. The place is small, but the variety of food was pretty amazing. Its also a great place if you are into micro brew beer; they had about 8 on tap and 50 on their drink menu.... More

This is a TINY place but when the weather is fine there is outside seating. Expect at least a 30-45 minute wait but boy-oh-boy is it worth it! Nice communal table, a small bar (maybe 5-seater) and several smaller tables. This place is just the best with great prices too. Try the special-of-the-day pizza and they donate to a local... More

I had searched for a place to eat on my first night ever in Door County. What a treat Wild Tomato was! It's a small venue, and it was packed. Luckily, there were some open spots at the counter. First, we had a glass of wine..we weren't sure about the option we were contemplating, so they gave us a taste.... More

We were looking for a casual restaurant with good food; excellent hand tossed pizza, fabulous beer selection, great cheese curds and delightful service. We got there before 5:00pm and by 5:15 all the tables were full. They have outdoor seating in the summer which would increase their capacity. Will definitely go back.

Local Favorite pizza and bread basket. Custom Cherry soda very good too! Generous selections of beers and staff very knowledgeable and helpful in making selections to match your tastes. Repeat visit - usually busy a good sign that food is great and people want to return for another great specialty pizza. Worth a try you will not be disappointed!

Stopped for lunch and not in the mood for pizza and ordered a sandwich. It was the traditional club. It was plan. It needed a garlic or bacon mayo. Ordered the fried curds. They were excellent. The batter was nice and fluffy. Not at all greasy. My husband ordered the burger. He said it was so so. My mom ordered... More