$50 for an adult on Mothers Day for a buffet where nothing rose above mediocre, and most fell well below. No seafood, tough prime rib, overcooked halibut.....a costly disappointment for what should have been a celebration.

$50 for an adult on Mothers Day for a buffet where nothing rose above mediocre, and most fell well below. No seafood, tough prime rib, overcooked halibut.....a costly disappointment for what should have been a celebration.
The Route 66 Brunch Buffet was a great start to our Sunday in Milwaukee. Mimosa's or Bloody Mary's to start and a great buffet including create your own omelet, carved ham and prime roast along a complete buffet of hot and cold selections... The Smyth also provided a menu to order unusual and tasty breakfast fare like; cranberry & golden...
More
Nice breakfasts, great burger for lunch, nice cheese plates. Nice bar staff. A little pricey but portions were generous, and we split a number of items. Small, but nice wine list.
I ate the best meal I have had in a long time at Smyth. Beautful food, great wine recommendation and great service, enjoyed it all. And what's more it wasn't fussy - it all just worked - WELL DONE!
I was curious how The Smyth would fare compared to the Iron Horse Hotel in terms of charm, so took a business associate to try it out. The interior at night was dark and mysterious. Servers were polite and helpful.
I sampled the surprisingly tasty wisconsin beer cheese soup (so much better than it sounded and wonderful- especially with the...
More
Great decor, however our food was over cooked, was very bland, and serving proportions were small. My wife and I left feeling disappointed.
The food was OK, although a neat place to visit for a drink. The menu is not very exciting as I was not sure what to order. I think out of towners think its a cool place but for the locals, just OK
Nice bartender and tasty drinks and appetizers makes for a fun time at Smyth. We also had a great breakfast there the following morning.
We went to the Iron Horse for a date night. Had fabulous pre-dinner drinks at Branded - the cucumber G&T was fab and the Gimlet had fresh muddled lemon and lime- delish. We each had 4 courses at Smyth and each was better than its predecessor. You really can't go wrong. Whether it is a special occasion or just a...
More
A trip to Milwaukee is not right unless you visit here. An old mattress factory now a hotel, restaurant and bar. Really cool place.
If you own or manage Smyth In The Iron Horse Hotel, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.
Manage your listing