We enjoyed a delicious prime rib dinner. We ordered the mega large 20 oz size and took the leftovers back to our suite to enjoy the rest of our weekend away. The soup was hot and tasty. The fresh bread was warm and flavorful. Cost was comparable to other supper clubs. The waitress was efficient and friendly. We would return... More

The Nightengale has consistently superior food fare. Their steaks, fish, et.al. plus potatoes and salads/soup are high quality. You will never be disappointed. When my brother-in-law comes (he has traveled everywhere state-side and abroad, and considers himself a connoisseur of food and drink), this is the only place I take him. Bar offerings are to live for as well...best Bloody... More

the decor is way old and unattractive and their prices have gotten too high, considering the lack of atmosphere

TU March 12th, 2013 ... My wife & I were on a visit to Sturgeon Bay area and used the Tripadvisor reviews to find this remarkable supper club. We arrived around 4:30 pm in time to participate in "Happy Hour" (4 - 6pm) specials. Great drinks at great prices ... $5 for 2 "Brandy Old Fashions"!! We were seated when... More

My boyfriend and I went there for the steak. He got the prime rib! They do not skimp on the meat. The steak was the best steak I've ever had. My only advice is go early! This places gets packed , and whenever I drive by its always busy. Great service!!

This is a very traditional Wisconsin supper club with a twist. The menu is a bit more creative and with many options. We opted for the prime rib, which was excellent! One of the best we have ever had. We will go back and try the fish fry our next time up.

The bartenders are good, the drinks are yummy, especially the after dinner ice cream drinks like a Pink Squirrel. This being our first time here we could have used a bit of guidance from the wait staff. My husband ordered the prime rib which was very good and I ordered the perch. We both got a choice of potato. My... More

This place is known for its Prime Rib and didn't disappoint on this visit. Unfortunately, the service was slow and the meal took almost 90 minutes. The pace was off throughout our meal; there was just too much time between drink and food order, soup/salad arriving, and then the main course. I'd recommend planning for a nice relaxing meal and... More

Took my middle monster there for his 19th birthday. He ordered the prime rib ... the largest they had. They came out with what looked like a roast. He completely enjoyed it