We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly. We support the following browsers:
"Before I proposed to my lovely fiance, she took me to Cancun Inn when it was in Middletown. Wow it's top notch Mexican at its finest. Great service, great food, the ambiance is second to none, and best of all the margarita's and Sangria are to die for! Ask for Israel he's the man! He treats his cust..."omers like his relatives. Fresh Mexican in NY! A must to go! Now that it's in Sugar Loaf instead of Middletown, my fiance and I still come back and we LOVE it!! The burrito's, fajita's, and their entrees are excellent! I recommend the aroz compollo and the chimichanga's and burritos.
" More >
"We eat here about once a month, and we are always greeted by name. The service is friendly, and we especially like having dinner by the fireplace in the rennovated upstairs dining room. its cozy and the food is really good. The downstairs dining room has a great view of the craft village, and the en..."trance has a large display case showing some of the works of the local craftpeople.
" More >
"We were looking for a decent Mexican restaurant to try near our small town, and came across the positive reviews for this one in Sugar Loaf, NY. Knowing the 'rural' area, we didnt expect it to be busy, & did not even think to make a reservation.
When we arrived Saturday night, we could not even fi..."nd a place to park-it was so busy! We went in & the hostess asked if we had reservations, and looked grim when we said no. However, rather than turn us away, or give us a crazy wait time, without hesitation she went out of her way to find a place to seat us within 10 minutes!
The server was very upbeat, personable, and took pride in the restaurant and what it offered. He went out of his way to take his time, make recommendations, and make us feel welcome.
We really loved the salsa, and fluffy fresh guacamole. I had read an old review that the food was 'bland' but I have no idea what that writer ate, because the Mexican Crabcake, and Salsa surely had a good kick to it!! The margarita was ...
" More >
TripAdvisor provides reviews, articles, recommendations and opinions on Sugar Loaf restaurants.
Reviews and advice on hotels, resorts, flights, restaurants, holiday packages, and lots more!