We chose this particular Best Western because of it's proximity to I-95 and also because we're involved with the BW Rewards program. As far as the "best hotel in Florence", that wasn't our concern.
I don't know we only stayed at the Best Western not at any other hotels. I can only speak for the Best Western.
Best Western, we have stayed there twice. Very friendly staff, nice room & delicious breakfast.
Get an answer from Best Western Inn staff and past guests.