We stayed at the sister casita located a few doors down and loved it. The accommodations were great, with full kitchen, all the amenities and a little private patio. The location was in a very convenient area, close to local restaurants and a few blocks walking distance to the square.
Casita H is located about 6-7 blocks from the Plaza, an easy walk. The facility worked very well for two couples, with two bedrooms, each with an ensuite bathroom. The kitchen was well set up for breakfast. There was a washing machine in the Casita as well. Overall, it was a very clean and comfortable place to stay in Santa Fe. We are two couples in our 70s.
While the location is great for walking to the old town, the Casita I is unlivable. We were 3 people and I can't imagine having 4 in here. The living room is so tiny you can barely open the front door without moving the couch. Speaking of the couch, it is literally a back breaker - so old and broken down it takes multiple pillows to use. Overall the place is dirty (see my photos of my new white slippers, walked from the bedroom to the kitchen and the soles were already filthy, and pic of the kitchen pots/pans - no way I'm cooking on this pile of junk). For the price of this dump, we could have stayed in a nice B&B or even a hotel room since we couldn't cook in the filthy kitchen.
First off, the location is excellent — we were able to walk virtually everywhere. Plus, easy access to highway for day trips to hike. Parking was easy, but heed the warning to lock your cars. We inadvertently forgot one night and our car was broken into. The manager was very kind in calling before our stay to check in and answer any questions. She also allowed us to check in early which was appreciated. We were in Casita H and appreciated having a washing machine and dryer in our unit. All of this said, I was most disappointed by the lack of cleanliness. Counters had crumbs and sheets had hair on them. It was very disconcerting. Overall, the unit was cramped as well as dated. It could benefit from some upkeep of floors, bathrooms, and beds.
We rented a two bed / two bath casita. The unit was clean and had a fully equipped kitchen and comfortable living room. Walk to plaza, shopping, restaurants, art galleries. Good value and convenience.