We eat at Tomato Charlie's every time we are on the Island. They have the best pizza and the staff is wonderful. Cant beat the price either.
1 - 10 of 302 reviews
We stopped in for breakfast yesterday and left hungry.... When we arrived the waiter told us to pick any table, it was easy as there were only 4 tables occupied. We sat down and waited.... And waited.... And waited..... No one ever came over to...More
This will get the award for worst pizza i ate in 2016. Dough with just cheese and ham thrown on, they dont even cut the ham in pieces, really greasy also. The pineapple tasted like nothing... Also overpriced, service was oke, not more then that.
We stay at the Occidental every year. Our first night and last night we get pizza at Tomato Charlie's. This year we had 3 other couples with us and they loved the pizza. We always order the pizza and take back to our room at...More
Went here for breakfast. The place was not busy at all. Ended up waiting over 30min for a simple breakfast. Overall service was poor. Food was ok, not great. Highly recommend Salt & Pepper for breakfast over this place.
We came here to get an inexpensive pizza dinner, and we ended up with a inexpensive dinner, but the pizza was very small. A 14 inch piza is heir large. This will feed 2 people, but certainly not 4 people. I would suggest ordering 2...More
The pizza was tasty and in my opinion, better than Casa Tua. Keeping in mind that both places are expensive for pizza, Charlie's gave us a pitcher of Balashi with each large pizza. (Admittedly, we got take out from Casa Tua so they may have...More
We were looking for a change in menu and opted for pizza to feed the family, Tomato Charlie's wasa great choice. Lot's of options for pizzas and sandwiches and reasonable priced if you're on a family budget. We ordered 2 pizzas to go taking them...More
Had to come back here again after the great service received last year from Louise Ann! And for the wine & pizza! I was so surprised when we walked in & were welcomed back by Louise Ann!! She not only remembered us but also remembered...More