Closed ... Tooo $$$$$$ and precious for st John ...more $ than their NYC place ! Odd combinations ..
1 - 10 of 531 reviews
My husband chose Fatty Crab for his birthday night out. I called a day in advance and their answering machine said to leave a message for reservations which I did. I got no call back. I tried calling again the next day and again left...More
This is our fourth year dining at the Fatty Crab. It is my son's favorite place on St. John. We would suggest sharing a number of small plates, and forget the entrees. Understand that dishes will come out when they are done, so eat family...More
3rd time visiting over as many years. Food was great as usual in mid March. Recent reviewers gave poor reviews, wonder if the rumor i heard that they were closing is true?
Atmosphere was very nice. Patio dinning, clean and very stylish. Service seemed not up to St. John's speed. Interesting drink selection and did enjoy several of those. Sushi rolls seemed over priced and were average in tasted. Probably won't return.
We had a nice table, staff was kind but food was average to poor. My kids chicken dish was just fried breading no chicken, fried rice was hard, no true great flavoring of dishes. Pork belly was only fat
Should have know when there weren't many people having dinner. MUSIC is obnoxious and loud. Food comes out when it is finished not together. Wife had Ramen, a soup like dish, I had fried chicken. (only chicken on the menu) Her soup was out 25...More
Decided to visit Fatty Crab based on user reviews and advertisements of new sushi menu. Girlfriend paid excessively (even on St. John) for a mediocre sushi roll containing 6 pieces. I was unimpressed by sliders. Would not return. **staff - as everywhere on St. John...More
Went for dinner with a group of six last week, we shared a bunch of plates: the Spicy beef sliders (BEST slider i ever ate), pad thai, fried rice, beef brisket, tuna poke, a sushi roll, and the greens. You should order three orders of...More
Don't let the location fool you, cute place, great food. Sushi was fabulous. At first look I wasn't excited about the menu selection but in the end very glad we went, food was really, really good.