I had grilled mahi-mahi for lunch, with sweet potato fries as a side. The fish was good too but the fries were perfect. I couldn’t stop eating. The place is nice, relaxed in a genuine manner.
1 - 10 of 158 reviews
I've been going to Conestogas for many years since moving to the Gainesville area in the early 90s. A very reliable consistent experience, and reasonably priced for what you get. The wait staff is always friendly and courteous, and efficient. The atmosphere is rustic, but...More
My sister and her husband took us here as this is one of their favorite restaurants. We were not disappointed. Food was very good and the servers were very friendly. Service seemed a little slow as they were not really busy and we were in...More
My wife and I ate her about a month ago and found the restaurant very satisfying. This restaurant has a "hometown" feel with good food and great service. My wife had the beef stew while I had the seafood platter. Both dishes were excellent and...More
I have been attending our Military Order of Devil Dogs growl (meeting) at the Conestogas restrurant once a month for almost two years. I have tried many of their entrays and have yet to be disappointed. Their salads are crisp and fresh, their steaks are...More
We had been going to Conestoga's for years. We stopped going once we felt the service had dropped and the restaurant needed a face lift. We gave it a try recently and our server, Brooke, was wonderful. Looks like the carpets have been replaced. I...More
Plenty of food with excellent customer service. Ice cream shop as you leave is the perfect finish to a great meal.
Had lunch and had the CFS! Excellent. Green beans really cooked and seasoned well. Great portion size. Others meals in my party looked fabulous. Wife had the cranberry, walnut, blue cheese salad. Outstanding! Would go back in a heartbeat!
Very friendly fast service, even when super busy. But the food itself has gone extremely down hill, taste like school lunch food... my family & I used to eat here often when we lived in Lake Butler, but we won't be back again on any...More