I previously reviewed Cafe 2825 in Aug 2018. Having returned in July 2021 I can tell you the quality of the meal we ate was at least as good! This is simply one of the best meals you will ever eat. The only negative thing...I can say is it is extremely difficult to get a reservation. Once you've gotten past that, however, you can rest assured you will have a unique experience. There are so many things you should order, so hopefully you have a larger and/or hungry group. Definitely get the fresh mozzarella, but beyond that you really can't go wrong. Enjoy your amazing face stuffing!More

4 of us went and have been there several times every summer season for years. Consistently a great restaurant with fantastic food.

Unbelievable long wait for reservations if you want in heee. But the Tuscan food was honestly so delicious highly recommended you to work on reservations here it is worth it. Out sever was very helpful with the menu as they should be but one of...our guest has reactions to certain foods. Our waiter knew what to do. Which was helpfulMore

I've called a million times and requested a reservation always for a week or week and a half in advance. They never ever call me back. How do you get them to call you back? I've even said I was flexible with the date and...time. STILL NO RESPONSE.More

My wife and i have been there before and the food and service was good. BUT try making a reservation is a problem. BIG PROBLEM . You have to call 7 days in advance and HOPE that they call you back. I recently called for...a Wed. Reservation a weeks in advance at 10:44 AM. NEVER GOT A CALL BACK. Called a second time, NO RESPONSE. WOULD NEVER STEP FOOT IN THE RESTAURANT EVER AGAIN...OVERATED !!!More

Sooo disappointing on the homemade mozzarella (fresh diced tomatoes; not sautéed in oil, etc); stuffed artichoke (no idea where this recipe came from); cacio e Pepe HORRIBLE...pasta was so overcooked and too thin; Entrees where fabulous as was the tartufo...wine list also lacking...

This was our first visit to Cafe 2825. It was highly recommended on different venues and far exceeded our expectations! Very small and cozy atmosphere. We spoke with the owner prior to ordering. He was very personable and gave us insight to his menu. The...table side prepared specialties are to die for and they're a must have! My wife and I shared the freshly prepared mozzarella, tomatoes with roasted peppers. The menus all looked so great, particularly the house specials. We ordered and shared twin lobster tails and shrimp with pasta and an overwhelming portion of chicken parm which we couldn't finish. We ended our wonderful dinner with cappuccino, expresso while sharing Tiramisu. Everything was unbelievably outstanding, so much we had to share our experience with the owner in person. We were treated like old friends. We only wish we lived closer so we could dine here more frequent. Highly recommend to anybody who visits AC. We'll be back to try other dishes and see the warm hearted staff. Our only disappointment is that we haven't been here sooner. BTW, this establishment is well prepared with Covid protocols in place keeping all patrons safe. Thank you Cafe 2825! See you soon!More