Every single time I go to Appleton, I go to this restaurant. And, their jarred sauces are amazing too!
1 - 10 of 861 reviews
First time there and can't figure out what the hype is about! Food was good. But the the atmosphere is loud ,"get the heck out of here so we can have your table" cattle run! It has a feeling of strip mall , Loud, Boring...More
Just returned to Carmella's for my birthday. It was wonderful, as usual. The soup of the day was an heirloom tomato with Italian sausage and was one of the freshest, most delicious soups I've ever had. I decided to go more traditional for my entree...More
An AMAZING meal all the way around! We had to wait a bit for a table (which is always a good sign to me) but we didn't mind one bit. The food and service were both EXCELLENT! Will definitely return when we are back in...More
Carmella's is a great restaurant. It is traditional Italian food, can be very heavy. My favorites are the fusilli with chicken instead of shrimp and the house made ricotta raviolo with pesto.
Closest to real Italian meal that we can get without going to Florence. I had the creamy fettuccine and it’s so rich and creamy. The atmosphere is a bit echo filled so it’s not always easy to have a conversation with friend though. There’s often...More
I love this restaurant! I come here once or twice a year and always look forward to it. The atmosphere is great. The past few times though it's taken quite a long time to get our food which is disappointing.
I called at 10am for call-ahead seating for two people on a busy Friday evening. We were greeted warmly when we arrived and welcomed into the bar to wait for our table. We waited only a couple of minutes. We were on a time-crunch and...More
We hadn't been here for a while. We were always pleased with the entrees so we went here to celebrate a family birthday. My daughter ordered the steak done medium. It was dry with very little topping. . It was served on a "slab" of...More
I have had the veal Marsala numerous times before and ordered it again as I really love it. This time I was sorely disappointed as there was very little meat served with the potatoes and mushrooms. Not their usual portion by any means.