The brats and dogs are great here, sides are really good as well, but my favorite is taking the food to sit down by the river that runs adjacent to the property. They have picnic tables set up at the waters edge for you. Really...More
1 - 10 of 77 reviews
We used to love going to the Coney in Conifer - for decades. They had AWESOME shakes and malts, good burgers, fries - everything you'd expect. After the move to Bailey, it was still good. But our most recent visit was just awful. They only...More
What a fun time. The cutest place with terrific owners. The dogs are terrific and unique. Try everything. I love the chili cheese fries and the Elk sausage. A wonderful patio outside with a beautiful water wheel. Love it.
I have been coming here for 17 years - first when they were in Aspen Park and now in Bailey, CO. A super fun place where you can eat your hot dog by the roaring creek.
Coney Island is just a bit further up the road from it's original location. It's a cool place to stop for lunch, so stop and enjoy a bit of historic charm.
On our way out of town, we try and stop at the Coney Island. It is a neat landmark in the community. Been there a half dozen times. The food is consistently good. There is always a long line, so bring your patience.
This was our first time visiting this place in it's present location. I came back to visit my family and decided to make the trek down nostalgia lane having frequented this place throughout my childhood. I can only say that I wish I had stayed...More
I read a few reviews before trying Coney Island, and wasn't sure what to expect. But, where else can you pull up to a huge hot dog in the mountains, watch a beautiful river rushing by, sit outside surrounded by massive pine trees, and eat...More
Mary Ruth, You are why we do this! Thank you so much for your thoughts here, it truly means a lot. We might not be all things to all people, so we love that you enjoy what we do here, we hope to see you...More
We've lived up in this area for 20+ years. We frequented Coney Island before the building was moved to Bailey, and have dropped in over the years at it's new location. However, we hadn't been there for several years, and were beyond disappointed. The menu...More
Fresh, delicious food. I am honestly surprised at the negative reviews. My husband can be a bit of a food snob and we really enjoyed our meal. Food was fresh, tasty, diner was super clean and tidy. I went to the original stand as a...More
Thank you Michelle. We really appreciate your opinion on us here- it means a lot to us. Your kind words make this worth it. We hope to see you and your husband soon.