I was picking up prepared food for home and remembered friends telling me to go to Gaetano’s. They were so right. Food was great. Salad perfect. And the people are just wonderful to deal with. Can’t recommend them enough.
1 - 10 of 18 reviews
I only have great things to say about this deli. The staff is great and never seem hassled even when the line is out the door. I get cooked eggplant here and cheeses. Cannot praise enough the person who makes the fresh mozzarella. It is...More
Friendly, efficient staff........they treat all their customers like friends. The sandwiches are all delicious- excellent fresh & authentic ingredients. The hot dishes are excellent as well. I love going to this place- even if the line is out the door....always worth the wait and the...More
Delicious Italian deli sandwiches, some of the best around. Fresh bread daily right out of Arthur Ave. in the Bronx. Yummy fresh mozzarella. Also have dinners pasta nd meats, A must try if you like good Italian food.
There is an active lunch crowd for a reason - the personalities behind the counter and the great deli sandwiches. Both are something to experience!
What a fantastic place. Wide selection of sandwiches - bread brought in from Arthur Avenue. Fresh Mozzarella made on premises. Friendly staff makes you feel as if you they have known you for a long time. Wish we had found this place sooner as we...More
The meat lasagna is fabulous. Raves from my Ital-American cooks. I introduced other foodies and they are believers (and buyers). Antipasto plate. Fresh cooked veggies. Excellent. After 20 years of eating on both sides (a Chinese and Japanese restaurant) we finally went in for a...More