Waited for the somewhat famous Pot Pies and was disappointed... Was hoping they were oooey gooey and they really had the consistency of dry mashed potatoes... I was expecting more deliciousness ! Sorry...
1 - 10 of 205 reviews
Waited for the somewhat famous Pot Pies and was disappointed... Was hoping they were oooey gooey and they really had the consistency of dry mashed potatoes... I was expecting more deliciousness ! Sorry...
We were celebrating my husbands 60th birthday in Key West. At the recommendation of the restaurant, I called this bakery three days before our trip and ordered a cake to send to the restaurant for his birthday dinner. The cake was absolutely beautifully decorated and...More
I live in Maryland and Needed a birthday cake. The restaurant where we were having dinner recommended Key West Cakes. Everything was done by email and Erin nailed it. The cake was PERFECT. . Such an easy and stress free experience . Thank you !
Thank you Key West Cakes for not only delivering a beautiful wedding cake for two, but for it also being the most delicious vanilla cake that we have ever eaten. Regardless that it was our wedding cake, the taste was so unbelievable for what is...More
Awww, thank you and congratulations.
Awesome key lime pie and cupcakes! Delicious! Staff also very friendly! Won't bei the last time we've been there.
We requested a carrot cake for our wedding cake. It was just my husband and myself. We managed to consume the entire 6" double layer cake in less than 48 hours. This was hands down the best cake I have ever had! The design was...More
I happen to be walking by when I saw this place. I bought the Oreo cupcake and it was delicious, but it was by pure coincidence they were cutting into a Buch Noel cake that had not gotten sold at Christmas and the cashier offered...More
My partner and I went to Key West Cakes for a cake tasting for our wedding. Because of this, we got to try a ton of flavor combinations. The problem we faced is everything was SO GOOD! Of all the cake flavors and fillings, there...More
Had one of these while walking down Duval Street during the Friday events of Fantasy Fest.. was great! I had a plain cupcake with orange icing...
I ordered a cake for a friend's birthday to be delivered to our hotel. It cost $40, plus $10 for delivery. I was disappointed that the bakery ignored my request to inform the front desk to deliver it to my room upon its arrival. In...More