The 2 ladies that were running the front were so funny & personable! They made our experience more memorable! We loved the pie. Not too sweet like other key lime pies! I love that they offer esspreso/Cuban coffee drinks too!
1 - 10 of 530 reviews
First, there is some confusion with the photos included with some reviews here. This is the Key Lime Republic. The Key Lime FACTORY is across the street. They look similar. We sampled the Key Lime Pies at both places back-to-back, and this one was the...More
Had my very first piece of key lime pie dipped in pie in this cute little shop once I arrived on the island. It was positively sinful! Had a cup of Cuban coffee to go along with it. Fantastic treat!
The Best! If you are looking for Key Lime Pie - This is the place! We've tried the others but will only eat here. Don't waste your time and calories anywhere else. You can buy it buy the slice or save some money and get...More
The customer service here was great. TIP for anyone visiting Key West on your birthday.... Let EVERYONE know it's your birthday. From free dinner cruises to free pie everyone offers you free items on your birthday. The clerks and the customers all joined in for...More
The Key Lime Pie and Key Lime Republic came in at #8 of 9. The pie consistency is closer to a cheesecake than a pie. The flavor is too sweet and lacks the tart lime bite. It's OK but there are too many other exceptional...More