You have to stop this ice cream shop, they have a lot of flavors to pick from I try few of them and I loved them.
1 - 10 of 147 reviews
Not only ice cream here but pasta, sauces, jellies and other goodies. Service is great, the owner is there often.
Wow!!! 16% butter fat & beyond words delicious!!!!!! Made in the Sarasota Amish community, this stuff is the real deal!!!! Fantastic assortment of flavors carefully "tweaked" to perfection. The banana was easily the best I've ever eaten & paired perfectly with the chocolate fudge. 😊...More
After dinner we decided to find an ice cream shop. We wandered into the Amish creamery and now this is the dessert spot. They have THE best ice cream in florida... made with 16% butter fat. You seriously will not find more creamy, flavorful ice...More
The icecream is very good and lots of varieties to choose from. I ordered the chocolate peanut butter icecream and hubby had the rocky road flavor and said it was the best he had ever tasted! The only downside to this place is not sitting...More
Just recently moved across the street to a larger store, much nicer and more flavors. We love this place. There are more well known and busier places in the area but this shop offers better flavors at a better price. We go multiple times we...More
My wife and I have been visiting Amish Creamery for almost 10 years. They recently moved across the street into a newer, better laid out store. We love the new place! Despite four dozen or so ice cream flavors, we are creatures of habit and...More
48 flavors of ice cream. They have moved, but are still very close by the original shop. 211 - 150th Avenue, Madeira Beach, FL 727-397-8222 ENJOY!!