Anyone who follows me knows that I am a pizza Maven. I have had pizza in the best and the worst of places and this is among the worst. I cannot imagine what people are used to for them to even say this is "pizza."...More
1 - 10 of 95 reviews
There aren’t many tables but the pizza is worth the wait! I cannot speak to anything but the pie, but this was true New York style.
Thank you, you get us! Hopefully you will try the wings and Zeppoles in the future. We hope to see you again soon. Mark, family and staff
My wife and I had a very good and enjoyable lunch at Rico's. We recommend it to anyone who may be in the area.
Mr. Gerald Braham, thank you and we look forward to serving you in the future. Mark Riley, family & staff
I had high hopes when I ordered 2 eggplant parmesan subs from the Gulf Gate Rico's on Monday evening. The sandwiches turned out to have no flavor. The sub roll was pale and doughy, the cheese was sparse, and the tomato sauce was bland. The...More
This sounds very disappointing indeed. You ordered our second most popular sub too so we've had lots of practice. We do make our bread daily and it is traditionally a little more dense than some are used to. As for the garlic in the sauce...More
The best pizza restaurant in sarasota! Top Service, top Pizza. We eat some pizzas in florida , but this is the best .
Büsra A! Thank you for coming in, so glad you enjoyed everything have fun on your vacation. Hopefully we'll see you again soon. Kindest pizza regards, Mark, staff & family
NY style pizza. An all around great pie. It has a lot of flavor. It cooked to a nice firm/crisp crust. I highly recommend Rico's pizza.
Thank you for the great review! Always striving to get that crust perfectly crispy. We hope to see you again and often. Mark, family & staff
My family have lived in Sarasota for 50 years... Eat at alot of resturants, also travel alot and this is a favorite of our's.... Real great food at a good price. Thanks ... Im glad we found you..The price for very affordable and worth every...More
Hello Kimberly, thank you for the nice words in your review, we love meeting and serving our guests what we believe is some of the best pizza and Italian dishes around. We are blessed with a great staff always learning, always changing and of course...More
Pizza was cold when it arrived. Drinks were not delivered. We ordered a cannoli, which was small and not good. I would not recommend this place and we are not picky eaters. Cost for a small pizza and a cannoli was $32.More
Mr Martin B, so sorry to hear about this. Did you call us back at the restaurant? These things do happen BUT we can and do correct them immediately or we give you all of your money back! Not sure how to address the cannoli...More
I am always amazed at how fresh and delicious their pizzas are. I have yet to have any better in Sarasota. The restaurant is small so I always carry out my pizza.
Woo Hoo Karla M! Thank you for your business and the very kind words. We will keep doing what we do and hope to see you again soon. Pizza, Love & Happiness Mark, staff & family
If you want the tastiest NY style pizza head to Rico's in Gulfgate! The nicest people and they best pizza in the Sarasota/Venice//Bradenton area!
WooHoo! We thank you for your business and awesome review! We look forward to serving you in the future....we'll keep the pizza oven hot for you. Kind pizza regards, Mark, family & staff