We loved their wings and pepperoni pizza! Their service was super fast and extra friendly- kudos to Tori. They have indoor and outdoor seating. One of our favorite meals in the Keys. We'll definitely stop in again.
1 - 10 of 473 reviews
In beween Miami and Key West there is a smaill restaurant thats a great stop for the whole family. Jersey Boardwalk Pizza is a family style restaurant with reasonable prices, great tasting pizza and most impressively, excellent customer service. Our waitress was a real, down...More
If you are ever down near Tavernier and craving pizza (instead of getting seafooded out), TRY THIS PLACE!!! I have lived in 7 states and 15 places and visited 38s states....... This is truly my favorite pizza of them all. The staff is awesome too!!
We have been going to Jersey Boardwalk Pizza in Tavernier on every trip to the Keys for years. Although we focus on the seafood when in the area, we enjoy Jersey Boardwalk and make at least one visit every time we are down. We are...More
On our last night in Key Largo we wanted something more simple and stopped here. Very glad we did, after eating in very nice seafood restaurants all week this was a welcome change. The pizza was good and the cheese steak I ordered was great....More
We grew up in towns near where the owners are from (according to the website) so this place piqued our curiosity when we visited the Keys. The service was great. We ordered a pizza and an Italian sandwich. The former tasted very close to what...More
I worked in a NY style pizza place making pizza's for 3 years in Charleston, SC and am also from upstate NY so I am a pizza snob. So a restaurant in the Keys with "Jersey" in the name peeked my curiosity. Needless to say...More
We came down for a few days. Decided to stop in real quick before seeing a movie. The staff was super friendly. Service was amazingly fast. While they were not busy when we stopped in, it was quick even taking that into consideration. Now the...More
OMG, this pizza by far was the best pizza that I have had in a very long time.......Cheesy lots of pepperoni just the right amount of sauce so so so good You have to try this if you are in the area!