Locally-owned and very welcoming to travelers. They gave me a free dessert because I was a new customer.
21 - 30 of 88 reviews
We love to come to Western Ribeye especially for the salad bar and the bread with apple or herb butter. We have had dinner for two here and also attended luncheons for 50. Either way the food is consistently well prepared and very tasty. It...More
I live in Durham, NC but my mother lives in Newburgh, IN and she is highly selective and her favorite present is my gift certificate I get her every year for dinner at the Western Ribeye. I have been there several times and would rate...More
The atmosphere was nice, quiet. Although, our food was not served at the same time, half of our table was finished before we were even given our food. We ordered several ribeyes and an order of the ribs. The side items were not great-pretty cold....More
The interior could use a little TLC though I'm sure this adds to the character. I can look past that. I had a sirloin steak sandwich with fries and the salad bar. It's a basic salad bar-not a wow. Jason's Deli has a nicer salad...More
my wife & I visit this restaurant 2 or 3 times a year. Local owners the Nix brothers. reservations would be good . they have the freshest salad & bread & cheese bar in town. We always seem to go for the Ribeye steak dinner...More
Our second visit in 3mos. Steaks and chicken cooked to perfection and salad bar was always fresh. Service was good and staff was friendly.
We (two of us) had a wait of 10 minutes to get seated at 6:30 on the Saturday after Thanksgiving. Totally reasonable time frame. NY strip was perfectly cooked and ribs were amazing. We will be back when we are in Evansville in the future!...More
Western Ribeye has been known for their salad bar for decades and it still measures up. Mega salad fixings, fresh blocks of cheese and their apple butter are still on the line. We eat there when we come to town and remember our waitress from...More
This is an extremely difficult review for me to write because I have enjoyed dining at Western Ribeye for over 30 years. Over the years we have watched as the quality of the food has steadily declined but because we could always count on good...More