I have been to Matteo’s numerous times over the last two years and it never disappoints. Staff are courteous and attentive to detail and the food is GREAT!
1 - 10 of 260 reviews
House made limoncello makes for one fantastic lemon drop with sugar rim! Piping hot bread, ordered nightly special bone-in pork chop parmesan and skipped desert. Too full! Staff is helpful and filled my daughter’s pink lemonade five times. She was happy! The other entrees ordered...More
My wife's meal of veal piccata was tough and flavorless, the substitute meal of ravioli was undercooked and hard. After 12 years of patronage I am afraid we will have to hear of a marked improvement before we go back. It is our suspicion that...More
It is nice restaurant with a great atmosphere... The service was good... but the food is just ok... A few dollars more than Olive Garden or Maggianos, etc.. but unfortunately, not as good.. I had the pasta with meat balls... the meat balls were good...More
No aroma of Italian flavors when entering this restaurant. The Shrimp Scampi was tasteless so I asked for chopped garlic to add to the tasteless dish. Shrimp wasn’t fresh. This wasn’t an “off” night, we were here early two years ago and this time we...More
Our party of 4 hungry eaters who are always hankering for exceptional Italian food were NOT disappointed by the variety of great food and excellent service once again! We're delighted that Matteo's winning formula will be expanded upon by opening more restaurants around Indy with...More
Matteo’s restaurant, I used to enjoy the Matteo’s restaurant in Noblesville (IN) during the lunch hours. Some food quality issues made us stop going. The new Matteo’s (Indianapolis) was on our agenda just to try it again. We arrived close to 5:00 PM on Saturday...More
Hi Zeeanton, My name is Franco and I'm the GM of Matteo's North Indy. First, I'd like to apologize about your experience with us. I've been in situations like this before and it is incredibly frustrating. This past Saturday, we had our party room booked...More
Matteo's deserves the moniker "Ristorante Italiano" because its thoroughly authentic Italian and one feels transported back to the 1920s by the beautiful decor. The booths were luxurious, the artwork was sublime. We went for lunch, which was not crowded. But they do a brisk dinnertime...More
Wonderful service and food. The atmosphere is lovely. Great for romantic meals, business lunches & celebrations. Reminds one of a cozy, almost elegant restaurant setting of years gone by.