My wife and I go here on a weekly basis. Great pizza and fantastic service. A little crowded in the summer, but after all, it's Maine and that's to be expected!
1 - 10 of 110 reviews
We were there toward the end of their season and grateful to have a meal. The restaurant was busy and maybe short staffed. My salad with beets was just OK. Our pizzas were also good. My guy and our traveling companions seemed more satisfied than...More
We've been visiting friends in Maine and tonight they took us out to their favorite restaurant, the Barncastle in Blue Hill. We ate outside on the porch which was very pleasant. I ordered an "ocean smoke" pizza (something like that): pizza with scallops, crab and...More
WE LOVE TO DINE HERE!!! The atmosphere feels like home. The service is A+ and friendly. The food is fresh and full of flavor. Although the menu has selective options you will understand why once you taste the food. As a family we take our...More
During the Winter season the Barncastle is always a treat. Food is good, service friendly and we can relax in a warm place - for a change during the Maine Winter!
This pizza place, although it serves delicious and heartwarming pizza, isn't your standard corner store pizza. You get sat at tables and the service is excellent. You leave feeling as though you're royalty who have just eaten at a quaint little pizza place in some...More
We have been going to Barncastle for years. It's a great place for a casual dinner with friends. Kids enjoy it too. Interesting menu and good food. Nice wait staff. However, we were not seated once because we were 5 minutes late - even though...More
on the way thru Elsworth and Surry in Maine. a nice upscale area with a market,gas station and this nice old restaurant. huge parking area. Old fashioned homelike location but each room is seperate for dining. a menu that has a bit of everything from...More